






| Proposition | Opposition |
| Shang Fa Enough arts/culture venues - In S’pore, we already have arts venues like Esplanade - > 7000 arts/culture activities last year - Erosion of own traditional cultures - No limit to culture, true. We already have more than enough avenues. Roadshows, museums. | Han Cong Repository for Past - Safekeep past, history and tradition - Promote culture, heritage, sense of identity - Relevance; no limit to culture - Learning from past mistakes; not just experiential. If cultures die, museum is the last place for us to remember. - SG is small and unique - Treasure our own culture and status - Need to emphasise SG culture - Man without culture = body without soul - Roots - As we continue to grow, land depleted. Heritage contents need to be preserved in a museum. Deepens understanding of others - Erosion: Museum promotes understanding of other countries. Caters to wide variety of interests - Museums for stamps, coins, army. Good egs. Widen perspectives of particular interests. |
| Wei Jie Economy - More job opportunities; museum does bring jobs, but theme park has more - Eg. Ticket sales, food. Museum = curator, guides, security - Museums = Longer and more stable jobs, but museums give much less jobs. Feed more people; giving more people a source of income. Saves more people. - Economic growth - Museum may be education; education fundamentally for economy - Man w/o culture = man w/o soul: In SG, we already have textbooks. Textbooks = soul. Museum = another soul. - Mass appeal: People interested in arts and culture a minority - Museums need funds | Jolene Tourism development - Museum: Tourism development - Travel agencies rather bring groups to museums Lack of Theme Park expertise - Theme parks require specialists / engineering expertise - Theme park competition; S’pore less likely to excel - Educational; people also learn culture and heritage - Visit SG for theme park or culture? Escape Theme Park or culture icons? Culture needs to be experienced - Not just internet: Culture is EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING. - Museums not easily replaced. Theme park is a significance of country’s wealth; museum = status and respect for a country. Lack of land - Themes parks are the same everywhere – Limited land area in Singapore. Tourists will go to better ones overseas. - Museum is a place for remembrance |
| Yi Fang Not enough culture to need a museum - Young country; only little culture here - Museum focuses only on SEA culture, rather than SG itself - We only have Jap Occupation history; not very significant - TP: more capital, more tourists - E.g. reasons for IR Experiential Learning of Culture does not need Ms - Festivals – experience culture. No need to have museums. - Museum not = experience of arts and culture. Try time machine. Or festivals. Accessibility - Theme Parks are for everyone. Museums have age restrictions. - Museum not as accessible as textbooks or internet. | Alvin Museums are a form of Entertainment too - Entertainment for the elderly - Museums for everyone; all ages from zero to elderly, unlike theme parks(?!) Relate to Globalisation - Globalisation: Our small culture needs to be preserved; need for uniqueness. Resist globalisation’s force of homogenisation. |
| Serene Importance of Entertainment - Both have entertainment value, but TP provides more - Museum only for interested people - If people are interested, they won’t need a museum. Textbooks, internet are sources of info | Rachel - Shang Fa said we have more than enough: There’s no limit to culture - Wei Jie: Job opportunities. But not stable income. Mostly part time - Yi Fang: SG is multiracial, SEA’s culture is ours. We have a mix. - Tourists come for our culture and food, don’t go just for theme parks. |
2)When an F1 driver hits the brakes on his car he experiences retardation or deceleration comparable to a regular car driving through a BRICK wall at 300kmph!!!
3)F1 car can go from 0 to 160 kph AND back to 0 in FOUR seconds!!!!!
4)F1 car engines last only for about 2 hours of racing mostly before blowing up on the other hand we expect our engines to last us for a decent 20yrs on an average and they quite faithfully DO....that's the extent to which the engines r pushed to perform...
5)An average F1 driver looses about 4kgs of weight after just one race due to the prolonged exposure to high G forces and temperatures for little over an hour (Yeah that's right!!!)
6)At 550kg a F1 car is less than half the weight of a Mini.
7)To give you an idea of just how important aerodynamic design and added down force can be, small planes can take off at slower speeds than F1 cars travel on the track.
8)Without aerodynamic down force, high-performance racing cars have sufficient power to produce wheel spin and loss of control at 160 kph. They usually race at over 300 kph.
9)In a street course race like the Monaco grand prix, the down force provides enough suction to lift manhole covers. Before the race all of the manhole covers on the streets have to be welded down to prevent this from happening!
10)The refuelers used in F1 can supply 12 liters of fuel per second. This means it would take just 4 seconds to fill the tank of an average 50 liter family car. They use the same refueling rigs used on US military helicopters today.
11)TOP F1 pit crews can refuel and change tyres in around 3 seconds. It took me 8 sec to read above point
12)During the race the tyres lose weight! Each tyre loses about 0.5 kg in weight due to wear.
13)Normal tyres last 60 000 - 100 000 km. Racing tyres are designed to last 90 - 120 km.
14)A dry-weather F1 tyre reaches peak operating performance (best grip) when tread temperature is between 900C and 1200C.(Water boils boils at 100C remember) At top speed, F1 tyres rotate 50 times a second.
Born of a vision to be the best
Rising above the rest
We speak with one clear voice
As this is our choice
Cause we are..
Born of a vision to be the best
Rising above the rest
We speak with one clear voice
Yes this is our choice
Meridian yes we will be
The best
Feel the flame of our dream
Burn forever
As our journey here begins
We're together
With each step we take we know
Strength to strength we'll grow
As we set ourselves apart
Facing challenges ahead
We will overcome
With passion fervour we will strive
Spread our wings and fly
We will reach the highest star
Through Meridian
Yes our hopes and dreams will shine
Born of a vision to be the best
Rising above the rest
We speak with one clear voice
As this is our choice
Cause we are..
Born of a vision to be the best
Rising above the rest
We speak with one clear voice
Yes this is our choice
Meridian yes we will be
The best